Index
Chapter 5 · Item 5.9
Hydrogen expectation values
Recurrence relations and parameter derivatives extract radial observables
9 / 10
Guided reading

Hydrogen expectation values can be evaluated directly from radial integrals, recursively through the Kramers-Pasternack relation, or by differentiating the energy with respect to a Hamiltonian parameter.

Radial moments
\[\langle r^q\rangle=\int_0^\infty R_{nl}^*(r)\,r^qR_{nl}(r)\,r^2dr\]

Useful closed forms include

\[\left\langle\frac1r\right\rangle=\frac{1}{n^2a_0}\]
Positive moments
\[\langle r\rangle=\frac{a_0}{2}\left[3n^2-l(l+1)\right]\]
\[\langle r^2\rangle=\frac{a_0^2n^2}{2}\left[5n^2+1-3l(l+1)\right]\]
Feynman-Hellmann theorem
\[\frac{\partial E_n}{\partial\gamma}=\left\langle\frac{\partial\hat H}{\partial\gamma}\right\rangle\]

Choose a parameter γ whose derivative isolates the desired operator.

Checks from the solutions

Differentiating the Coulomb Hamiltonian with respect to e reproduces \(\langle r^{-1}\rangle=1/(n^2a_0)\). Treating l as a parameter in the radial Hamiltonian yields

\[\langle r^{-2}\rangle=\frac{1}{n^3a_0^2(l+1/2)}\]
Using Feynman-Hellmann as a shortcut

If \(H(\gamma)|n\rangle=E_n(\gamma)|n\rangle\), differentiating and using normalization cancels derivatives of the state, leaving \(dE_n/d\gamma=\langle\partial H/\partial\gamma\rangle\). The method converts knowledge of the energy spectrum into an expectation value. The parameter must be treated consistently in both Hamiltonian and energy.

Checking the hydrogen moments

The result \(\langle1/r\rangle=1/(n^2a_0)\) depends only on n, consistent with the virial theorem for a Coulomb potential. By contrast, \(\langle r\rangle\) and \(\langle r^2\rangle\) also depend on l because the centrifugal barrier shifts probability outward. Dimensional analysis checks every formula: \(\langle r^q\rangle\) must carry length to the power q.

Worked reasoning sequence

Use the following chain when working with Hydrogen expectation values. First identify the symmetry, prepared state and observable being discussed; this determines which basis and quantum numbers are meaningful. Next write the operator or differential equation before substituting eigenvalues. Apply boundary conditions, commutators or normalization one step at a time, keeping dimensions and allowed quantum-number ranges visible. Only then simplify to the highlighted result. Finally translate the mathematics into a measurement statement: specify which outcomes are possible, which quantities remain uncertain, how degeneracy is counted, or where probability is concentrated. This sequence prevents a correct formula from becoming disconnected from the physical assumptions that justify it.

Self-check: Radial moments, Kramers-Pasternack relations and Feynman-Hellmann methods for extracting observables. The final answer should explicitly connect this objective to at least one equation on the page and one experimentally meaningful prediction.

Choose the efficient method

Direct integration is transparent for low states; recurrence relations generate families of moments; Feynman-Hellmann is fastest when the target operator appears as a parameter derivative.

Exercise-ready boundary

This page is designed to support short guided exercises on: Radial moments, Kramers-Pasternack relations and Feynman-Hellmann methods for extracting observables.

  • Use from this page: the definitions, physical setup, highlighted equations and conceptual links needed to start a first calculation or explanation.
  • Keep in the book: complete derivations, extended discussion, worked solutions and the full textbook narrative remain in the original chapter and linked book resources.
  • Good exercise balance: identify assumptions, apply one relation, and interpret the result physically, without requiring material not introduced on this page.
Practice anchors

Use these anchors to design compact exercises. The exercise should be answerable from this page plus standard algebra, while longer derivations, full worked examples and broader context should point back to the original book.

  • Focus: Radial moments, Kramers-Pasternack relations and Feynman-Hellmann methods for extracting observables.
  • Conceptual check: state what the main result says physically before using it algebraically.
  • Key equation 1:
  • \[\left\langle\frac1r\right\rangle=\frac{1}{n^2a_0}\]
  • Key equation 2:
  • \[\frac{\partial E_n}{\partial\gamma}=\left\langle\frac{\partial\hat H}{\partial\gamma}\right\rangle\]
  • Typical task: derive, interpret, or apply one relation to a simple case without introducing topics outside this page.
  • Boundary: use this page for setup and first-step reasoning; cite the book for longer derivations, complete experimental history or solved-problem detail.
Source note: Original auxiliary summary for this book-app, based on Chapter 5 of Mario Reis, Quantum Mechanics, Elsevier, 2026. Book text and figures are copyright © 2026 Elsevier Inc.; consult the original book for the complete presentation, derivations and exercises.